Why ethics is in a course about law
A dealer can file every form on time and still lose the license, because one ground for discipline is not a form or a deadline. After notice and a hearing, the DMV may suspend or revoke a dealer license when the dealer has caused any person loss or damage by fraud or deceit practiced on that person, or by fraudulent representations made to that person, in the course of the licensed activity (Vehicle Code 11705(a)(14)(A)). This lesson is about that ground and the laws beside it that judge how you dealt with a person. The lesson on unlawful activities and enforcement covers the other grounds.
What the code means by fraud and deceit
Fraud is more than a lie told on purpose. Under 11705(a)(14)(B), fraud includes what the Civil Code calls actual fraud and constructive fraud, deceit means what Civil Code 1710 says, and both include:
- A misrepresentation of a material fact in any manner, whether intentionally false or due to gross negligence.
- A promise or representation not made in honesty and good faith.
- An intentional failure to disclose a material fact.
- Any act within Penal Code 484, the theft statute.
Actual fraud is any of five acts done by a party to a contract to deceive the other party or to induce the contract: suggesting as fact something untrue that you do not believe; asserting something untrue in a manner your information does not warrant, though you believe it; suppressing something true that you know or believe; promising with no intention of performing; and any other act fitted to deceive (Civil Code 1572). Deceit adds asserting an untruth with no reasonable ground for believing it, and suppressing a fact you are bound to disclose or that your other statements mislead without (1710). Constructive fraud needs no intent to deceive: it is a breach of duty that gains the person at fault an advantage by misleading another to that person's prejudice (1573).
Three rules follow. Do not say what you know is false. Do not state as fact what you have no ground to believe: if a salesperson says "never been in an accident" without looking at the history report and the car was in one, believing it is no way out of the definition. And do not stay silent about a material fact you know, or tell half of it. A person, for this ground, includes a governmental entity (11705(a)(14)(C)), so a false statement that costs the DMV or the tax agency money is covered too.
What you say to sell the car
The standard for a statement to the public is what you should have known. A licensee may not make or spread, in any manner, a statement that is untrue or misleading and that is known, or by the exercise of reasonable care should be known, to be so (Vehicle Code 11713(a)). It is not only about ads: the California Supreme Court read it to reach what a salesperson tells one customer (Ford Dealers Assn. v. Department of Motor Vehicles (1982) 32 Cal.3d 347). "I did not know" is no answer if reasonable care would have told you.
The Consumers Legal Remedies Act lists practices that are unlawful in a transaction intended to result, or that results, in a sale or lease to a consumer (Civil Code 1770(a)). Among them: representing that goods have characteristics or benefits they do not have (paragraph 5); advertising goods with intent not to sell them as advertised (9); making false or misleading statements about the reasons for, existence of, or amounts of price reductions (13); representing that a transaction confers rights, remedies or obligations it does not have (14); and misrepresenting a salesperson's authority to negotiate the final terms (18). A consumer damaged by one may sue, and a prevailing plaintiff is awarded attorney's fees (1780).
Since October 1, 2026 the CARS Act, SB 766 (Chapter 354 of 2025), adds a list written for car dealers. It is a violation to misrepresent material information about, among other things, the costs or terms of buying, financing or leasing; any aspect of an add-on; whether a consumer has been or will be preapproved or guaranteed for any product, service or term; whether you will keep a down payment or a trade-in, or charge fees, if the deal is not finalized; whether and when you will pay off a trade-in; and any affiliation with or approval by a government agency (Civil Code 1784.40).
The price you agreed and the charges you add
The deal the buyer agreed to is the deal you write. It is unlawful for a dealer to negotiate the terms of a sale or lease contract and then add charges for goods or services without first disclosing them to the consumer and getting the consumer's consent (Vehicle Code 11713.19(a)(1)). It is also unlawful to inflate an installment payment or a down payment, or to extend the term, to disguise what the added goods or services cost (11713.19(a)(2)). Neither needs proof of fraud: any violation of the dealer article is a misdemeanor and a ground for discipline (40000.11(a); 11705(a)(10)). The lesson on the conditional sales contract teaches the add-on disclosure the buyer signs first.
The buyer who is easier to mislead
Some buyers are less able to protect themselves, and the law gives them a claim of their own. An elder is anyone living in this state who is 65 or older (Welfare and Institutions Code 15610.27). A dependent adult is a resident aged 18 to 64 whose physical or mental limitations restrict normal activities or the ability to protect their rights (15610.23(a)). Financial abuse of either happens when a person or business takes or obtains their property for a wrongful use, with intent to defraud, or by undue influence. A taking is for a wrongful use when the person knew or should have known that it was likely to harm them, and depriving them of a property right by an agreement counts as a taking (15610.30(a) to (c)).
Undue influence is excessive persuasion that overcomes a person's free will and results in inequity. A court weighs the person's vulnerability, including age, illness and impaired cognitive function, and whether the influencer knew or should have known of it; the influencer's apparent authority, which includes standing as an expert; the tactics used, haste among them; and the fairness of the result, though an unfair result alone does not prove it (15610.70). A defendant found liable for financial abuse pays the plaintiff's attorney's fees and costs on top of the damages (15657.5(a)). When a buyer seems confused about what they are signing, slow down, invite them to bring a family member, and do not close that day if the confusion remains.
When you negotiate a sale primarily in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese or Korean, the buyer gets a translation of the contract before signing (Civil Code 1632(b)); the lesson on Truth in Lending has the rule. Do not use the buyer's weaker English against them.
Equal treatment in price and credit
Equal treatment reaches which car you show, what down payment you ask and what rate you quote. The Unruh Civil Rights Act entitles every person in this state to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges and services of every business establishment, whatever their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language or immigration status (Civil Code 51(b)). Since January 1, 2025 the section says the list includes any combination of those characteristics (51(e)(7)(A); SB 1137, Chapter 779 of 2024).
For credit, the federal Equal Credit Opportunity Act makes it unlawful for a creditor to discriminate against an applicant, in any aspect of a credit transaction, on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, sex, marital status or age, for an applicant able to contract; because income comes from public assistance; or because the applicant used a right under the Consumer Credit Protection Act in good faith (15 USC 1691(a)). A dealer who arranges financing is a creditor here. The term covers a person who, in the ordinary course of business, regularly takes part in a credit decision, including setting the terms, and for the rules against discrimination and discouraging applicants, one who regularly refers applicants to creditors or selects the creditors to whom a request is sent (12 CFR 1002.2(l) and 202.2(l)).
None of this sets your price or stops a buyer from negotiating a better one. It forbids a difference that rests on a characteristic on either list. When two buyers with the same credit leave with different terms on the same car, be able to state the reason.
Other people's money
Much of what passes through a dealer's account belongs to someone else. When you take a trade-in in a retail sale or lease and it still has a loan or lease balance, you tender the payoff to the legal owner or lessor within 21 calendar days of taking the vehicle: the amount your written agreement names if it names one, otherwise the amount needed to discharge the balance (Vehicle Code 11709.4(a)(1) and (2)). You may not sell, consign or transfer the trade-in until the amount needed to discharge the balance has been tendered (11709.4(a)(4)). Until then the buyer still owes on a car they no longer have. When a buyer pays you more for licensing or transfer than the fees actually due, you return the excess whether or not the buyer asks (11713.4). The lesson on registering the car covers the fees.
You answer for the people who sell for you
A salesperson's promise is the dealership's promise. A licensee who runs the business through employees answers to the licensing agency for what they do under the license, a salesperson's statements to a customer included (Ford Dealers Assn., above). A person who suffers loss by the fraud or fraudulent representation of a licensed dealer, or of a salesperson acting for the dealer or within the scope of the employment, and who holds a written instrument from the dealer with provisions the person believes were violated, has an action against the dealer, the salesperson and the surety on the bond, up to the value of the vehicle (Vehicle Code 11711(a)). So train your salespeople, and read the messages they send. Since October 1, 2026 you keep every written communication about a sale, financing or lease with a buyer who signed, for two years (Civil Code 1784.44(a)(2)); the lesson on electronic contracts and online sales explains.
When you find your own mistake
Suppose you find one: a fee collected twice, a payoff sent late, a disclosure left out of a file. Fixing it does not undo a violation. A payoff tendered on day 30 was late under 11709.4, and it stays a ground for discipline after the lender is paid (11705(a)(10)). What a prompt correction does is stop the loss. The fraud ground turns on loss or damage to a person, and its definition includes an intentional failure to disclose a material fact. Once you know and keep quiet, the silence is a choice. So tell the customer, return the money, correct the record, and write down what you did and when.
Sources
- Vehicle Code 11705, grounds to suspend or revoke a dealer license, paragraphs (a)(10) and (a)(14); 11713(a), untrue or misleading statements; 11713.19, added charges and inflated payments; 11709.4, payoff of a trade-in's balance; 11713.4, refund of excess fees; 11711, the action on the bond; 40000.11(a), the misdemeanor rule, read 2026-11-17.
- Ford Dealers Assn. v. Department of Motor Vehicles (1982) 32 Cal.3d 347, California Supreme Court, on Vehicle Code 11713(a), a salesperson's statements and the dealer's responsibility for them, read 2026-11-17.
- Civil Code 1572, 1573 and 1710, actual fraud, constructive fraud and deceit; Penal Code 484, theft, read 2026-11-17.
- Civil Code 1770, the Consumers Legal Remedies Act, unlawful practices; 1780, the consumer's action, read 2026-11-17.
- Civil Code 1784.28, 1784.40 and 1784.44, the CARS Act (SB 766, Chapter 354 of 2025, operative October 1, 2026): operative date, misrepresentations and records, read 2026-11-17 on the code and in the chaptered bill.
- Welfare and Institutions Code 15610.23, 15610.27, 15610.30, 15610.70 and 15657.5, dependent adults, elders, financial abuse, undue influence and the civil remedy, read 2026-11-17.
- Civil Code 1632, contracts negotiated in a language other than English, read 2026-11-17.
- Civil Code 51, the Unruh Civil Rights Act, as amended on January 1, 2025 by SB 1137 (Chapter 779, Statutes of 2024), any combination of characteristics, and AB 1815 (Chapter 619, Statutes of 2024), a definition of race that includes hair texture and protective hairstyles, read 2026-11-17 on the code and in the chaptered bills.
- 15 USC 1691, the Equal Credit Opportunity Act; 12 CFR 1002.2(l) and 12 CFR 202.2(l), the definition of a creditor in Regulation B as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the Federal Reserve Board each publish it, read 2026-11-17.
- DMV, Lesson Plan Guidelines for Used Vehicle Dealer Education Programs, OL 2000 (rev. 12/2007), part G and topics 11 and 19.