What changed since 2024
Four things in this subject changed in the last three years.
- On October 31, 2024 the California Supreme Court decided Rodriguez v. FCA US, LLC (17 Cal.5th 189): a used vehicle bought with an unexpired manufacturer's new car warranty is not a "new motor vehicle" under the Lemon Law's refund-or-replace remedy unless that warranty was issued with the sale.
- AB 1755 (Chapter 938 of 2024, in effect January 1, 2025) added court procedures for Lemon Law suits, Code of Civil Procedure 871.20 and following: a filing deadline (871.21), a written demand before a claim for civil penalties (871.24) and early mediation (871.26). SB 26 (Chapter 1 of 2025, in effect April 2, 2025) applies them only to a manufacturer that elects them (871.29). They govern suits against manufacturers and leave every duty below in place (871.20; 871.28). AB 1849 (Chapter 196 of 2024, in effect the same day as AB 1755) amended Civil Code 1791 and 1793.2 for travel trailers and motor homes.
- The CARS Act, SB 766 (Chapter 354 of 2025), took effect October 1, 2026 (Civil Code 1784.28). It forbids misstating a material fact about an add-on's cost, limits or benefit (1784.40(b)) and charging for a service contract that a preexisting condition makes void (1784.42(a)(4)). It has you pay an add-on's provider within 10 days of the signing unless your agreement with the provider allows later payment without affecting the buyer's coverage (1784.42(b)), and keep for two years copies of every service contract and proof of that payment (1784.44(a)(3)).
- In the Insurance Code, AB 1140 (Chapter 204 of 2023, in effect January 1, 2024) limits an obligor that insures its service contracts to one active policy on file (12830(d)), and AB 487 (Chapter 558 of 2025, in effect January 1, 2026) widened who counts as a service contract administrator (12800(d)). AB 943 (Chapter 566 of 2025) reworded 12815 without changing who needs a provider license.
The warranties a used vehicle leaves with
A used vehicle leaves your lot one of three ways: with an express warranty you wrote, with only the implied warranty the law supplies, or as is. An express warranty is a written statement, arising out of the sale, by which the seller undertakes to preserve or maintain the goods' utility or performance, or to compensate the buyer if they fail (Civil Code 1791.2(a)). The words "warrant" and "guarantee" are not needed to make one, and a statement of value or an opinion does not make one (1791.2(b)). The implied warranty of merchantability means the vehicle passes without objection in the trade and is fit for the ordinary purposes a vehicle is used for (1791.1(a)). With no written warranty and no as-is writing, a dealer's sale carries it under Commercial Code 2314.
An as-is sale is how you sell without it. The waiver works only by an as-is or with-all-faults sale that strictly follows the Song-Beverly Act (1792.3): a conspicuous writing attached to the vehicle that tells the buyer, before the sale, that it is sold as is, that the entire risk as to its quality and performance is the buyer's, and that the buyer pays for any repair (1792.4; 1792.5). The lesson on the Buyers Guide on your lot says where that writing goes.
As is has limits. It does not undo a warranty you wrote (Commercial Code 2316(1)). Under the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act a disclaimer of implied warranties is ineffective if the seller gives a written warranty on the vehicle, or enters into a service contract with the buyer at the sale or within 90 days after (15 U.S.C. 2308). An as-is sale waives no disclosure: the buyback papers below are owed all the same. And it bars the word "certified" (Vehicle Code 11713.18(a)(7) and (8)).
What you take on when you write a warranty
A dealer that gives an express warranty on a used vehicle takes on the duties the Song-Beverly Act puts on a manufacturer (Civil Code 1795.5). You, not the vehicle's maker, maintain service and repair facilities in California to carry it out (1795.5(a)). The implied warranty of merchantability then runs as long as your express warranty, but not less than 30 days or more than three months after the sale, and three months if your warranty states no duration (1795.5(c)).
The vehicle is repaired to conform within 30 days unless the buyer agrees in writing to more (1793.2(b)). If after a reasonable number of attempts you cannot make it conform, you replace it or refund the price, less the amount attributable to the buyer's use before the buyer discovered the defect (1793.2(d)(1)). Time the vehicle spends in your shop for a warranty repair does not count against the warranty, and the warranty does not expire if the repair failed and the buyer told you so within 60 days. Each warranty repair gets a work order or receipt showing the dates (1795.6).
The Lemon Law
The line to retire is that a used vehicle "still has Lemon Law protection" because factory coverage remains. The Lemon Law is the Act's remedy for a new motor vehicle the manufacturer cannot conform to its express warranty after a reasonable number of attempts: the manufacturer promptly replaces the vehicle or makes restitution, and the buyer may always choose restitution (Civil Code 1793.2(d)(2)). The Tanner Consumer Protection Act presumes the attempts were enough when, within 18 months of delivery or 18,000 miles, whichever comes first, a nonconformity likely to cause death or serious bodily injury has been in for repair two or more times, the same nonconformity four or more times, or the vehicle has been out of service for repair more than 30 days in all (1793.22(b)). A nonconformity substantially impairs the vehicle's use, value or safety (1793.22(e)(1)).
A "new motor vehicle" includes a dealer-owned vehicle and a demonstrator or other motor vehicle sold with a manufacturer's new car warranty (1793.22(e)(2)). In Rodriguez all seven justices held that the phrase means a vehicle for which a manufacturer's new car warranty is issued with the sale, and disapproved Jensen v. BMW of North America (1995) to the extent it is inconsistent.
What a used buyer has is the repair promise in whatever factory warranty remains, from the manufacturer, and whatever express warranty you wrote, from you. The opinion notes the argument that such a buyer can still sue on a transferable warranty under the Commercial Code. It reads 1795.5 to put the Act's liability for used goods on the seller that gave a warranty and not on the manufacturer, at least where the manufacturer issued no new warranty and played no substantial role in the sale. Say that, and no more: a statement you know, or should know, is untrue or misleading is a violation (Vehicle Code 11713(a)).
Lemon Law buybacks on your lot
When a manufacturer takes a vehicle back under the Lemon Law, it retitles the vehicle in its own name, has the DMV inscribe "Lemon Law Buyback" on the title, and affixes a decal to the left front doorframe, which no one may knowingly remove or alter (Civil Code 1793.23(c); Vehicle Code 11713.12). No one may sell it, at wholesale or retail, unless the nonconformity is disclosed to the buyer, corrected, and warranted in writing by the manufacturer for one year (1793.22(f)).
Two papers are yours at resale, each signed by the buyer before the sale. The first is the notice Civil Code 1793.24 prescribes, owed when you know or should know that the manufacturer reacquired the vehicle after its last owner asked for a replacement or a refund (1793.23(e)). It is owed whether or not the title is branded, and you get an executed copy from your seller (1793.24(a)(2) and (c)). The second, owed when the title reads "Lemon Law Buyback", is the separate statement that the vehicle was repurchased by its manufacturer due to a defect (1793.23(f)). A buyback may never be sold as certified (Vehicle Code 11713.18(a)(2) and (3)). The lesson on disclosing a vehicle's history has the notice's contents.
Service agreements
A service contract, the service agreement of the DMV's outline, is a contract sold for a separately stated price and a set term to repair, replace or maintain the vehicle, or to pay for that, when a part fails from a defect or normal wear (Insurance Code 12800(c)(1); Civil Code 1791(o)). The price is what separates it from a warranty, which comes at no charge beyond the vehicle's price (16 CFR 455.1(d)(5) and (7)).
Only a seller may sell or offer a vehicle service contract in California, and a seller is a dealer or lessor-retailer licensed by the DMV that sells them incidental to its vehicle business (Insurance Code 12810(a); 12800(f)). You may not lend your name to a third-party obligor as a front (12810(b)). The obligor, the party that owes the repairs, holds a vehicle service contract provider license from the Department of Insurance unless it is the dealer itself or the vehicle's manufacturer or distributor (12815(a); 12805(c)). A licensed obligor and a dealer that is its own obligor alike have an approved insurance policy covering 100 percent of their obligations, or a net worth of $100 million, behind them (12830(a); 12836; 12805(a)(2)).
The contract may cover only items, costs and time periods the express warranty does not, or add a remedy the warranty lacks (Civil Code 1794.41(a)(3)). The buyer gets the contract, or a brochure describing its terms, exclusions and cancellation rights, at or before the purchase, and the contract itself within 60 days (1794.41(a)(2)). The contract states its price conspicuously, with the obligor's name, address, telephone number and provider license number (Insurance Code 12820(b)(3)). An exclusion for preexisting conditions is in 12-point type (12820(b)(4)). Read it against what you know of the vehicle before you offer the contract: you may not charge for one that a preexisting condition, such as prior crash or flood damage, makes void (Civil Code 1784.42(a)(4)). The charge is itemized in the conditional sale contract (2982(a)(1)) and listed with its price on the add-on disclosure the buyer signs first (2982.2).
The buyer can cancel. Within 60 days of receiving the contract, or 30 days for a used vehicle without a manufacturer's warranty, written notice brings a full refund if no claim was made and a pro rata refund if one was. After that, the refund is pro rata, and the seller may keep a cancellation fee of 10 percent of the price or $25, whichever is less (1794.41(a)(4)). On a financed contract the refund may be made payable to the lender. The obligor may cancel within 60 days of the sale if the contract reserves the right, and at any time for nonpayment or the buyer's fraud (Insurance Code 12825).
What a violation costs
The DMV may suspend or revoke a dealer license, after notice and a hearing, for a violation of the Vehicle Code's dealer licensing article, where the certified-vehicle rule and the buyback decal are; for a violation of the Civil Code's chapter on conditional sale contracts, where the add-on disclosure is; and for a loss caused by fraud or deceit, which includes a misrepresentation of a material fact, intentional or grossly negligent (Vehicle Code 11705(a)(10), (12) and (14)). A violation of the Vehicle Code's occupational licensing division is a misdemeanor (40000.11(a)).
A buyer damaged by a breach of the Song-Beverly Act, of a warranty or of a service contract may sue, and a buyer who wins recovers costs and attorney's fees. A willful violation can add a civil penalty of up to two times the actual damages, except on a claim for an implied warranty alone (Civil Code 1794). Selling a buyback or an as-is vehicle as certified is actionable under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act and the Unfair Competition Law (Vehicle Code 11713.18(b)). The CARS Act sets no fine of its own: its remedies add to those of other laws (Civil Code 1784.22), and the DMV's memo on the Act, OLIN 2026-10, names those two laws, suspension or revocation of the license, claims on the bond and restitution for prohibited add-ons.
Sources
- Civil Code 1791, 1791.1, 1791.2, 1792.3, 1792.4 and 1792.5, the Song-Beverly Act's definitions and the as-is sale, read 2026-11-17.
- Civil Code 1793.2, 1793.22, 1793.23 and 1793.24, the refund-or-replace remedy, the Tanner Consumer Protection Act and the resale of a reacquired vehicle; 1794, the buyer's action; 1794.41, service contracts; 1795.5 and 1795.6, express warranties on used goods, read 2026-11-17.
- Rodriguez v. FCA US, LLC (2024) 17 Cal.5th 189, S274625, decided October 31, 2024, the opinion as published by the court, read 2026-11-17.
- Code of Civil Procedure 871.20 to 871.30; AB 1755 (Chapter 938, Statutes of 2024), SB 26 (Chapter 1, Statutes of 2025) and AB 1849 (Chapter 196, Statutes of 2024), chaptered texts, read 2026-11-17.
- Civil Code 1784.22, 1784.28, 1784.40, 1784.42 and 1784.44, the CARS Act, and 2982 as re-enacted (SB 766, Chapter 354, Statutes of 2025, sections 1 and 3), chaptered text; 2982.2, the add-on disclosure, read 2026-11-17.
- Insurance Code 12800, 12805, 12810, 12815, 12820, 12825, 12830 and 12836, vehicle service contracts; AB 1140 (Chapter 204, Statutes of 2023), AB 487 (Chapter 558, Statutes of 2025) and AB 943 (Chapter 566, Statutes of 2025), chaptered texts, read 2026-11-17.
- Commercial Code 2314 and 2316, the merchant's implied warranty and words that negate an express warranty, read 2026-11-17.
- 15 U.S.C. 2308, the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act on disclaimers of implied warranties; 16 CFR 455.1(d), the Buyers Guide rule's definitions of warranty and service contract, read 2026-11-17.
- Vehicle Code 11705, grounds for discipline; 11713(a), untrue or misleading statements; 11713.12, the Lemon Law Buyback decal; 11713.18, certified used vehicles; 40000.11, the misdemeanor rule, read 2026-11-17.
- DMV industry memo OLIN 2026-10, Implementation of CARS Act (SB 766), read 2026-11-17.
- DMV, Lesson Plan Guidelines for Used Vehicle Dealer Education Programs, OL 2000 (rev. 12/2007), part G and topic 20.